All Our Flavors

Check out what makes us famous! The Comfy Cow has been serving the Louisville area since 2009. Each flavor is unique, engaging, inspiring, individual and of course, delicious. Scroll down to find a flavor for your next Comfy Cow visit.

comfy cow menu

The Menu

The Basics


The flavor you grew up loving!


Just how you remembered it.

Strawberry Fields Forever

Always hand-made.

Georgia Butter Pecan

One of our award winning flavors!
Award Winning Flavors

Bourbon Ball

Made with a healthy pour of Old Forester Kentucky Bourbon.

Brown Butter Peanut Brittle

Ice cream filled with peanut brittle pieces.
Classic Flavors

CoCo Nutty

Rich coconut ice cream.

Cookies & Cream

Made with real Oreo's!

Minty Chocolate Chippy

Cool mint flavored ice cream.

Cookie Dough

Chocolate cookie dough - yum.
Fan Favorites

Chatty Cathy

Strong coffee ice cream with crushed chocolate covered espresso beans and chocolate chips.

Black Raspberry Chip

Raspberry flavored ice cream loaded with chocolate chips.

Salted Caramel

Caramel delight.

Cake Batter UP

Blended with pound cake pieces


Sugar Cone

Cake Cone

Handmade Waffle Cone

Halloween Season

Trick Or Treat

Sweet cream ice cream, pieces of Reeseā€™s, Heath, Butterfinger, and M&Ms, with a caramel swirl.

Pumpkin Toffee Nut

Rich pumpkin ice cream, bits of toffee and hazelnut, with a ribbon of butterscotch (the winner of the Pumpkin Picking Contest).
Christmas Season

Waiting For Santa

Ice Cream Pies

Cookies & Cream

Our homemade chocolate graham cracker crust filled with Cookies and Cream, hot fudge, and covered in crushed Oreos.

Bourbon Ball Pie

Our Award Winning Bourbon Ball ice cream layered with hot fudge, pecans and chocolate chips.

The "BFF"

Our signature Chocolate and Vanilla ice cream with layers of caramel and hot fudge and topped with chopped Heath bar pieces.

Betsy's Love Shack

Homemade chocolate graham cracker crust filled with Salted Caramel ice cream, hot fudge and pecans.


Our Strawberry Fields Forever, Chocolate and Vanilla ice cream layered with hot fudge and strawberries and topped with peanuts.

The Buzzzzz

Homemade chocolate graham cracker crust filled with our signature Coffee ice cream, caramel, and topped with chocolate covered expresso beans.

The Scooter

Homemade Minty Chocolate Chippy ice cream, hot fudge and sprinkles in a chocolate graham cracker crust.

*Ice Cream Pies are available and can be made with any of our seasonal or signature flavors. Please allow 72 hours notice when ordering a cake.

Giant Cookies


Chocolate Chip










Doggie Treats

Pooch Pops

Homemade frozen treats for your four-legged friends! Made with plain yogurt, peanut butter, blueberries, bananas and vanilla extract.


Dipped Bananas

Dipped Bananas with toppings